I discussed the many advantages or probability estimation over classification. Here I discuss a particular problem related to classification, namely the harm done by using improper accuracy scoring rules. Accuracy scores are used to drive feature selection, parameter estimation, and for measuring predictive performance on models derived using any optimization algorithm. For this discussion let Y denote a no/yes false/true 0/1 event being predicted, and let Y=0 denote a non-event and Y=1 the event occurred.

Optimum decision making in the presence of uncertainty comes from probabilistic thinking. The relevant probabilities are of a predictive nature: P(the unknown given the known). Thresholds are not helpful and are completely dependent on the utility/cost/loss function.
Corollary: Since p-values are P(someone else’s data are more extreme than mine if H0 is true) and we don’t know whether H0 is true, it is a non-predictive probability that is not useful for decision making.

© 2018 · Powered by the Academic theme for Hugo.