Viewpoints on Heterogeneity of Treatment Effect and Precision Medicine

This article provides my reflections after the PCORI/PACE Evidence and the Individual Patient meeting on 2018-05-31. The discussion includes a high-level view of heterogeneity of treatment effect in optimizing treatment for individual patients.

Clinicians' Misunderstanding of Probabilities Makes Them Like Backwards Probabilities Such As Sensitivity, Specificity, and Type I Error

Optimum decision making in the presence of uncertainty comes from probabilistic thinking. The relevant probabilities are of a predictive nature: P(the unknown given the known). Thresholds are not helpful and are completely dependent on the utility/cost/loss function. Corollary: Since p-values are P(someone else’s data are more extreme than mine if H0 is true) and we don’t know whether H0 is true, it is a non-predictive probability that is not useful for decision making.